Current Progressive Dairy digital edition
Advertisement

Is your milking parlor restricting your productivity?

Jason LeGassick for Progressive Dairyman Published on 31 March 2016
Milking parlor

First and foremost, dairies need to understand what restrictions there are in the milking parlor. A restriction is anything that impairs or constricts the milk path from the cow to the milk pipeline. This could be anything in the milk path.

Some of the culprits are claws and milk hoses with too small a diameter for the flow rates or production of the milking herd. Milk meters that restrict milk through a small hole to measure the milk or one that needs to weigh milk without having a consistent vacuum are also causing milk to be restricted.

advertisement

advertisement

It is most likely that any type of milk yield indicator is restricting the productivity of your cows. The biggest and most influential restriction is any time milk is lifted; lifting the milk causes a slug to form, drastically limiting the amount of vacuum that can get to the teat end of the cow.

Lifting milk can be found in many different places in the milking parlor. It could be as simple as milk hoses that are too long. It is also often found in milk yield indicators or in milk meters that need to lift the milk in order to measure the amount of milk going through the device.

How to know if there are any milk restrictions in your milking equipment?

There are a few different ways to tell if the milk from your cows is getting restricted from your milking equipment. The first and perhaps the easiest and most visual way to check is to watch the milk hoses coming off the claw.

Are the hoses bouncing at all? If so, this is visually showing you that there is a slug of milk being formed in the milk path.

Second, a dairy can have its technician from its local dairy equipment dealership check the average claw vacuum. If the vacuum is fluctuating more than a couple of tenths of inches of vacuum during peak milk flow, then the milk is being restricted.

advertisement

Last, the dealership technician can check the vacuum on the inlet and outlet side of the different pieces of equipment along the milk path, and if there is a vacuum drop over the piece of equipment, this then is showing that the particular piece of equipment is restricting the milk path.

The vacuum drop comes from the piece of equipment being “full” of milk and not letting the appropriate amount of vacuum pass further up the milk path.

Why would there be a problem now? I know what you are thinking: You have had the equipment for a while and there is no problem with it, or these are the same-size hoses and claws they have been selling for years. It is true; the same 5/8-inch hose, claw and equipment has been sold for years; in fact, 5/8-inch hose became popular in the late ’70s.

Let’s take a look at how cows and dairy farming has changed in the last 35 years. The average milk production of a 1980 herd of cows was 11,900 pounds, or about 40 pounds of milk per day. Today’s dairy herd is averaging 22,000 pounds of milk, with top herds averaging near 34,000 pounds; that is a daily herd average of 80 to 105 pounds of milk per cow per day.

With that increase in milk production, we now ask our cows to go through the parlor faster and give that increased milk production to us in less time.

However, as milk production has increased through the years due to advances in genetics, housing and nutrition, the majority of dairies have not yet updated the milking system to compensate for the increased milk production. The question is: How do we get more milk through our system faster?

advertisement

Does having restrictions in the milk path really even matter?

What happens when the milk path has restrictions? First of all, restrictions cause an unstable claw vacuum. Claw vacuum is essential to making a milking system work optimally.

2 gallon per minute  showing restrictions

In order to properly set up a milking system, a technician will need to establish what liner the dairy will be using, and then the technician will set the system to what the average claw vacuum will need to be.

The issue is: When you have slugs or restrictions in your milking system, the average claw vacuum fluctuates tremendously, sometimes as much as 5 inches of vacuum. With the fluctuations in vacuum, it will lower the average claw vacuum. Therefore, in order to compensate for the lower average claw vacuum, due to the fluctuation, the technician will raise the entire system vacuum up.

This is not the best solution for the situation, but with restrictions in the milking system, this is the only option. The higher vacuum will be an issue at the start and the end of milking, when the flow rates of the cow are not at peak levels. At this time, the teat ends will be exposed to a higher-than-necessary vacuum.

Another issue is: As the claw vacuum fluctuates, the cow will not be able to get the full and proper vacuum level to milk out quickly; this slows down flow rates and possibly hurts her overall production. The liner may also not function properly with fluctuating claw vacuum, as it takes a delicate balance between vacuum at the teat end and atmospheric air in order to have proper liner function. An improperly functioning liner will lead to slower milkouts and lower flow rates.

What can you do to solve the issues?

First, the dairy needs to eliminate all restrictions in the milk path. This can be done with larger-diameter equipment. The larger diameter allows milk and vacuum to pass simultaneously without restricting each other. Think of it as a water drainpipe; what happens if you have too small of a drainage tube?

The water gets backed up, causing flooding; now take that same amount of water and put it through a drainpipe twice as big. The water will run smoothly and quickly through the pipe without causing any issues.

The larger-diameter milk path will allow the cow to give milk at full flow rates, without the need of raising the system vacuum to compensate for the small-diameter milk path. This will increase flow rates and should improve teat health.

Liners will be able to function as they were intended. All this will allow the dairy to milk cows more efficiently with fewer overall issues.  PD

Jason LeGassick is a sales and marketing manager with Beco Dairy Automation Inc. Email Jason LeGassick.

PHOTO: Staff photo.

LATEST BLOG

LATEST NEWS